The Plum Trees by Victoria Shorr
While attending a funeral of one of three sisters who had survived Auschwitz, Consie, a modern day Jewish descendant, was given a letter from her relative’s estate. The letter written just after the War, stated that Hermann, Consie’s great uncle, had escaped from Auschwitz. This staggering news, set Consie on a quest to see if that could be true, because she was unaware of anyone ever escaping the death camp. As a result of that information, Consie began researching the audio recorded interviews made by Auschwitz survivors telling their stories about what happened in hopes of finding some further information about Hermann to see if, in fact, he had escaped.
With the information she gleaned from many sources, Consie pieces together the history of the lives of Hermann’s family, both before and during the Holocaust. This novel is horrific in places, but very well written and deeply moving.
I was especially struck by the deep confusion felt by Hermann and his family when the Nazis and their supporters first began to take power in Czechoslovakia. The prosperous family owned a plum orchard, and were well liked , because of their generosity and kindness toward their employees, neighbors, and towns people, but then slowly, as Nazism began to spread through their rural community, their lives began to be evermore restricted by ridiculous anti-Jewish laws.
Hermann was always a good and generous citizen, who had faith in the goodness of people, and so he ignored a chance offered by his brother who lived in America, to immigrate there.
He believed that the Nazi thing would soon blow over, and things would return to normal. Of course, things didn’t get back o normal, and instead became fatally worse. Soon, it became too late for Hermann and his family to leave for the US. They did manage to escape to Hungary, where things hadn’t yet gotten bad for Jews, but soon it too was engulfed by Nazism.
Over and over Hermann just couldn’t believe what was happening. The people that used to be friendly suddenly were hostile. People who he had helped, turned against him. He couldn’t make his rational mind accept what was happening to his country. In light of what is happening in to the US with the election of Trump, I can certainly relate to that feeling of unbelief and confusion.
Another interesting fact brought out by the novel was the pseudo-kindness and politeness espoused by the Nazis, to get the Jews to leave their homes to go to “do farm work” and live in “family camps”. “So sorry about the terrible boxcar train ride you had to take to get here” and “just take off your clothes, fold them nicely, so they will be here after you take your shower.” The acceptance of this false politeness worked until it was too late for the victims.
Historical fiction is my favorite reading genre. I found this novel on our library’s Libby app; downloaded it, and read it on my iPad. I was somewhat hesitant about picking it to read, because of its title and its cover, which seemed rather cartoonish, considering the description of the story it told. Although shocking in some of its content, it is based on the many recorded true incidents of those who survived the death camps.
However like I said, it is very well written, deeply moving, and certainly relevant considering the march toward authoritarian governments today. More people need to read things like this, because even if history doesn’t exactly repeat itself, like Mark Twain said, “It rhymes.”
Take a look at my paintings: davidmarchant2.ca